I just finished reading Natan Last’s 2025 book Across the Universe: The Past, Present,
and Future of the Crossword Puzzle. It was… fatiguing. Now, I myself am a “discursive”
writer, so I’m throwing stones from a glass house here; but it seemed to me that Last’s
every paragraph consisted of three or four anecdotes halfway told, capped off with some
nonsensical simile. Open the book at random to page 31:
On December 11, 2022, Eric [Albert] suffered a hemorrhagic stroke of his cerebellum.
He’s lucky to be alive: around 50 percent of patients die in a month, half of those within
the first two days. When we first spoke in April 2023, I immediately asked if his language
had been affected, then regretted it. But he was fine, he said. The neurologists don’t know
why the stroke happened, or how he recovered his cognition so quickly. He says he repeated the
French he was learning to himself in the ICU. I imagined him, was almost ashamed to imagine him,
saying ciré ciré ciré, épée épée épée — as if the accent marks were stray neurons in need of repair
— or an item from James Joyce’s Finnegans Wake I’d just seen in Word Ways because it’s the
only “word” with five or more Q’s: Quoiquoiquoiquoiquoiquoiquoiq! In Joyce’s Wake, it’s
preceded by the line: “He lifts the lifewand and the dumb speak.” I remembered analyses of
Broca’s aphasia I’d read studying neuroscience in college […]